Pinch vs grigri reddit My mate wasn’t pleased as his rope developed some gnarly kinks in the last few pitches. 5 and 11 mm. I will use a grigri, but I absolutely cant stand the Cinch. Pinch strength and crimp strength are somewhat related but mainly use different muscles to achieve the goal of holding on to the hold and not falling off. Bought a new Grigri and it wiggled and made a lot of noise and had to tape it. Sewn runners have the benefit of being able to be used as full-strength anchors in a pinch. From what you wrote I got the impression, that the GriGri can fail IN SPITE of being used correctly (something in the device brakes or idk. I feel like it's lighter and smaller than my grigri (but never weighed them. We did notice a big difference with the lock off of the GriGri 2 on a 9mm rope. theDIHEDRAL Team. "Active assisted braking" is the primary reason people pick Petzl GriGri 2 over the competition. And those were absolutely garbage for giving slack quickly or making a soft catch. Currently I can only belay top rope, but I will take a lead course in a few weeks. big fan. GriGri, specifically for top-belay I recently attended a two day trad. . May 11, 2019 · The issue was bringing up the second. It functions just like a GriGri, but it has a panic handle. This means your partner can likely use yours in a pinch, give you feedback on your technique, and there will be more people to help you with any questions you may have. To sum it up, if you want to avoid GriGri, don't go for its more annoying cousin. The BD Rocklock fills the hole in the grigri properly and minimizes this effect. Jun 18, 2024 · Das PINCH von Edelrid basiert auf demselben Prinzip wie das GRIGRI von Petzl – durch Zug am Lastseil entsteht Reibung an einem Bremsnocken, der das Seil abklemmt. It is what you should be learning on. Jan 10, 2025 · HowNot2 took a closer look at the Pinch and tested it in various situations. Jun 4, 2024 · Mit dem Pinch ist Edelrid ein großer Wurf gelungen. EDIT: Alpine Up is about 12mm longer than the grigri. r/onebag is an 'urban' travel community devoted to the idea of helping people lug around less crap; onebag travel. no need to change anything at the anchors. One last minute detail is the Edelrid Pinch can be attached directly to the anchor without a locking carabiner. That said, it stays at home because the grigri can do the same thing (better) and more. In his latest episode, Ryan Jenks from HowNot2 spoke to Edelrid athlete Tommy Caldwell and discussed the belay device with the professional climber pinch Caldwell uses the Pinch in numerous climbing situations, sometimes even for non-approved applications. Sometimes, in a pinch I'll use my gri-gri to rappel off a single pitch route I've cleaned, but I'll only do this if I don't have my ATC that day or forgot it on the ground, because it's not so nice to the rap rings. Jan 10, 2025 · Seit Edelrid das Sicherungsgerät Pinch auf den Markt gebracht hat, ist eine Diskussion entflammt, welches Gerät das Bessere ist: Pinch oder Grigri. The grigri is best suited when trying out moves on TRS or easy climbs. The GriGri, on the other hand, is quite a bit cheaper, and weighs almost one ounce less. Dec 5, 2024 · The GriGri is always in lead mode, which still works fine for top-roping if you keep your hand on the brake strand. Although Kochendörfer prefers an ATC or an alternative device to the GriGri, he admits that there are some situations in which the GriGri excels: “The only occasion where we use GriGri-like devices is Aug 28, 2024 · For the longest time, the Petzl GRIGRI has held strong to the #1 seat in the world of cam-assisted blocking belay devices, also known as assisted braking belay devices. Dec 14, 2020 · The Vergo slays the GriGri. Devices that are industrial rated that work similar would be. This page is powered by a knowledgeable community that helps you make an informed decision. It is more heavy and the autocamming allows it to be a device that does lots of extra things really easy. Your head is closer to the device when your weight is on the belay loop vs your feet and that extra few inches was enough to get her hair fed through and stuck. Whether it's because you forgot your device, it's on the rope, or life. A grigri locks up better and more consistently. Jan 22, 2025 · Anthony’s theory is that the added resistance comes from the Pinch’s visibly smaller rope channel (vs. I've seen some super Jun 20, 2018 · For long belays, the GriGri 2 is a blessing (as are belay glasses) Value. The grigri is the gold standard for a reason. Possible, but not the best solution. I mainly use atc myself, or grigri if the climber prefers that. ). The + has a stainless steel insert where the rope runs to improve longevity in this spot that commonly wears out, while the GriGri does not. Apr 21, 2025 · Well, for those who have used the GriGri, the Pinch will feel quite familiar, because whilst they are different in some ways they are still similar in terms of the fundamentals. The GriGri would lock up some of the time but some of the time start to slip and require extra resistance from your brake hand. I use an ATC for the gym and most toproping, especially with thick 11mm+ ropes, and a Reverso 4 for all lead belays -from above and below - and anything involving a skinny rope <9. Grigri (+): Die Unterschiede. This is nice because with the GriGri, the only time I'm really worried about a new climber making a mistake is during lowering. Use a Grigri. WARNING: with NEOX, but also with GRIGRI and GRIGRI +, on thin or new ropes, if the rope isn't held, it will slide through the device under i The GriGri + is a belay device best suited for very new climbers belaying on top rope. Once everyone is in the first anchor, start again with grigri. If bringing the Grigri, leader gets a Grigri belay and follower gets an ATC auto-blocking plaquette belay. Any thoughts are appreciated - thanks! Most of our climbing (nearly all) is going to be indoors, and right now we are toproping more often than now but will be doing a lot of lead climbing as well. Pinch - a new belaying experience with the PINCH, a new, versatile assisted braking belay device for use in sport climbing, multi-pitch climbing and rope access techniques. Its a very similar device, in that it loads/feeds just like an atc, but has the auto-assist capability, provided by using clever shaping of the device to cause the fall force to pull the biner into a pinch point, where the rope gets pinched between the biner and the device. Der Hebel des Pinch wirkt zwar robuster als der vom Grigri, allerdings liegen die Finger beim Abseilen näher am Seil, was im Direktvergleich eine Spur weniger komfortabel bewertet wurde. i know its an unfamiliar technique, but there is no rope slip. GriGri2 pays out slack very easily when you get the hand positioning right, makes the falls/hanging a lot more comfortable (especially when the belayer is off the ground), prevents rope slip when people are hanging, and lowers very smoothly. m. " However, the Grigri is overall a safer belay device. Like the Edelrid Pinch, the Petzl GriGri is made of an aluminium body with stainless steel components. Like the other commenter mentioned, a good setup is the Trango Vergo and some backup progress-capture device. Pre-sewn loops of 6mm cord "specifically made" for rap backup loops are really silly. The grigri + only has the advantage of having an extra breaking system for beginners using the device that might freak out when lowering and pull the lever too far back. a Grigri) and steel, V-shaped rope groove (as opposed to the way the Grigri twists the brake strand over a rounded lip). Other active assisted braking devices (devices with a moving cam, like the Camp Matik) tend to be at least as pricy. Keep in mind, there is a learning curve to Grigris (and most assisted braking devices, but Grigris and similar especially). Update 2019: Das alte, also das Grigri2, wurde inzwischen überarbeitet. This feeding and lowering system is smooth and optimised for ropes between 8. ) Mar 16, 2025 · use the following search parameters to narrow your results: subreddit:subreddit find submissions in "subreddit" author:username find submissions by "username" site:example. Just looked this up to double check. That is all when holding on to There’s a little handle/ledge for your thumb on the grigri 2 that is not on the grigri plus, so i wound up “downgrading” to a grigri 2 that i actually prefer. Grigri is often presented as the safest choice, but most of the (thankfully only) near accidents I’ve experienced, has been because people have used the grigri wrong. I really liked the Grigri for top roping. (I saw the other fplb topic, but I'm interested specifically in an ABD being used, while that one is more generic) I'm interested in using an assisted braking device (ABD; Giga Jul, Mega Jul, Pinch, GriGri, similar) (EDIT: in this post, I've sometimes conflated autotubers like the Jul's with semi-automatic devices like the Pinch or GriGri - they have different functions) while belaying direct A grigri is my personal favorite belay device for gym and sport. This mechanism stops the rope if the belayer pulls the handle too hard or loses Sep 21, 2023 · The GriGri uses an internal mechanism to pinch the climbing rope anytime the rope is pulled quickly through the device. Aussehen: Äußerlich gibt es keine großen Unterschiede. Mar 8, 2017 · Warum jetzt noch einmal ein neues Grigri, kann man sich da fragen. The mega jul probably does everything you want, but the consensus is that it doesn't do everything as well as a grigri and a reverso or atc guide combo. When leader reaches first anchor, set the ATC for top-belay. Oct 7, 2024 · Therefore, there is no advantage of hauling with a Petzl Neox over a Petzl GriGri or the Edelrid Pinch. With the Edelrid Pinch hitting the market, we are all wondering if it will push the GRIGRI out of the #1 spot or if it will do what “The belayer must continuously hold the brake side of the rope, even while the climber is stopped. For most users, a GriGri 2 will last a few years with no problems. If cost is keeping you from getting a grigri then the atc is perfectly fine. Black Diamond ATC Guide best practices vs. I figure by the time it wears out completely the ropes will be thinner by then and I’ll need a newer grigri anyway. I did prefer my old original GRIGRI for my Mountaineering Instructor work as it worked well with my fat ‘jugging rope’. If you want an assisted braking device, spend the money and get a grigri. A slider bar along the top of the device must be positioned all the way on either end, denoting either manual or assisted mode, and then the rope must be loaded into the device in the correct manner depending on the mode, which is different for each. PINCH vs GRIGRI - The pinch slips at a higher force on skinny ropes but lower forces on fatter ropes compared to the grigri. It puts a very tight bend in the line, and it's friction slowing/stopping the rope travel. Das Einzigartige an diesem Gerät ist, dass es direkt in den Gurt eingehängt werden kann, ohne dass ein Karabiner dafür benötigt wird. When comparing Petzl GriGri 2 vs Edelrid Mega Jul, the Slant community recommends Petzl GriGri 2 for most people. It's really hard to choose a belay device without using it first, though. I've found the Rocklock will cross load on occasion, so I picked up a DMM Rhino to keep the grigri on one end of the biner. They are both about the same size (Reverso 3 was tight) and definitely tighter then an ATC. While the pinch uses your thumb muscles, it uses a different finger muscle, the Lumbricals. Jul 24, 2019 · The Petzl GRIGRI is the undisputed winner of the popular vote among actively camming units. org/hardiseasy to get a 30-day free trial and get 20% off their annual subscription. But in too many cases, it’s not the device we would reach for. I've seen the Edelrid Pinch and love the fact that you can clip it directly to the belay loop. This is because the Grigri is auto-blocking while an ATC belayed from a harness is not. The ATC, on the other hand, cannot arrest a fall if the belayer releases the rope. For all you know they'd be just as sloppy if they were belaying with an ATC. I don't like using a Grigri for follower belay because the rope backfeeds easily, especially on steep pitches. I learned to lead belay over 15 years ago, before the Grigri 2 came out, and we just had the clunky original grigri. Standard Grigri. If it is a long multipitch, carrying an extra abseiling device may be advisable (I personally dislike lowering with a grigri on a multipitch). This device can connect directly to the harness (or anchor for a top down belay) without a carabiner passing through the two closed loop. Use an ATC on trad climbing or if you are using half/twin ropes. However, the GriGri is not particularly great for that either, so I use a DMM Pivot for that. On multi-pitch outings, we like a more streamlined (and lighter) device. i've done it on up to nine pitches and it was very fast and easy. Written by Seiji Ishii Jun 04, 2024 12:01 a. GriGri 2 vs GriGri new (2019) i am thinking what to get, what experiences do you have with that improved geometry petzl claims they honed out? how is paying out slack comparable, how about fast lowering, thick ropes with weird routes and even weirder draw placement, creating a lot of friction by themselves, when even ATC friction seems excessive? We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. It's ever so slightly ligher than the GriGri 2, but the biggest benfit is that I think it feeds better than the GriGri. Leader is belayed on a Grigri, while carrying the other belay device. The document has moved here. HowNot2 hat sich das Pinch genauer angeschaut und es in verschiedenen Situationen getestet. May 14, 2024 · The GRIGRI is great for belaying both lead and top rope, and with its anti-panic handle, the GRIGRI+ is optimal for top rope and learning. Jul 25, 2024 · We have even reviewed a couple on the site – the GRIGRI and the GRIGRI+ and the GRIGRI is my belay device of choice. Since I usually climb with my girlfriend, this could be a problem. It also has some advantages over the grigri. Design: It has the classical, time-proven design and includes a cam-assisted braking mechanism. For example, in the case of a lead fall, the rope pulls upward on the GriGri Jun 19, 2023 · The Petzl GriGri is a cam-assisted belay device, essentially meaning that the GriGri will brake in the event a climber starts to fall. 1/3 the weight of a grigri, and 1/2 the cost. For some, that’s a worthy expense to replace their GRIGRI devices. Posted by u/B3ta2k0 - 17 votes and 94 comments Either one is perfectly fine. As a gear nerd it was fun to try but it’s not the device to buy. Does anyone have experience with the Pinch? How does it feel compared to the Grigri? Jan 20, 2025 · Petzl GriGri Features. I've heard that lowering climber with Birdie is heavier compared to GriGri. It is a grigri fundamentally, with the rope running around a pulley instead of directly on the front of the cam. It’s a reasonable solution, adds little weight, provides an imperfect but usable backup should he drop his Guide, and equips him for self-rescue (a Guide, two friction hitches, and a sling make for a rope ascending system in a pinch. Clipping the GriGri direct to the belay was way more faff that using a guide plate – in the end I gave up and used an Italian hitch. The Grigri, Smart, Click Up, and Mega Jul are all going to be better devices. Following on it’s huge success, Petzl released an additional model, the Grigri+ in 2017. More expensive, heavier, super crappy modulation for lowering and I found it comparably impossible to feed slack without the device locking and me being forced to thumb down the camming mech. I don't think I've used a lever to lower device since I used my mate's Eddy quite a lot but that's well over ten years ago. com Anyone have a chance to try this out and get a feel for how the action compares to a GriGri in hand? The ability to set up the device in a vertical position without the use of a carabiner seems a bit gimmicky, and I’m curious if it is actually just a single button release on the brake-hand side. Carries an ATC. The GriGri is the most common belay device you will encounter in the world of sport climbing. Apr 22, 2015 · I simply want to discuss a small change to the way a belayer holds the Grigri that may make the "pinch method" slightly safer: instead of pinching the Grigri between the thumb and the index finger, try hooking the index finger under the lip of the Grigri and apply constant pressure to push the Grigri away from the harness (this is the key James and Steve McClure walk us through the New @PetzlSportVideos Neox. The GriGri 2 isn’t cheap, but it’s still a decent value. Jun 6, 2024 · Petzl NEOX vs GRIGRI vs GRIGRI + Benjamin Eaton. They both function well as progress captures and reduce friction efficiency in the hauling system at about the same level. Side note if anyone is still reading this thread. Sep 7, 2020 · The original Grigri was released back in 1991 and was updated to its current model in 2011. Nov 28, 2023 · Bei Hebeln dieser Länge (Pinch 8 cm, Grigri+ 10 cm) und kleinen Bremsnocken braucht man beim Abseilen stets ein feineres Händchen. I understand why people prefer the Grigri. The hand guard is also helpful, but if you know how to properly hold a grigri it's more of a nice fit (the guard is nice too). The grigri2 I’ve had for 10 years now is still working fine. This was a good thing; (photo/Seiji Ishii) The Edelrid Pinch is the assisted belay device Dec 13, 2023 · The Best Device to Use in a Pinch Most guides carry both the GriGri and the ATC, but in a pinch, they may rely on one device over the other. See full list on outdoorgearlab. Follower is belayed in guide mode. LIVE AN UNUSUAL AND EXCITING LIFE!!•••For the longest time, the Petzl GRIGRI has held strong to the #1 seat in the world of cam-assisted blocking belay devic Grigri plus is basically designed for new climbers, it's not a "new" or "upgraded" model. It's much the same as in the EpicTV video (Jul2 vs Pilot belay test) where he shows two methods to lower - one is to use your thumb to lift the device while having that hand still around the brake rope (same position as regular belaying with it), and the other is to pinch the device with thumb and two fingers. June 6, 2024. The Grigri needs some weight below it to engage such as some free hanging rope or a third hand. ET Share this: Pinch - a new belaying experience with the PINCH, a new, versatile assisted braking belay device for use in sport climbing, multi-pitch climbing and rope access techniques. grigri goes, then atc raps as soon as grigri is at next anchor. 5mm, an extremely broad range which is likely to cover most people. I wouldn't buy a grigri with grooves and poor action for any price. Lead or top-rope belaying with the Giga Jul can be done in either assisted braking or manual mode. There is no need to use that loop of slack, it's not a great method to use anyway, and if the climber falls at that moment the loop will all become slack before the GriGri locks. Newer Post Pinch vs GRIGRI. Moved Permanently. The grigri on the REI site is the grigri 2019. In the question “What are the best belay devices for rock climbing?” Petzl GriGri 2 is ranked 1st while Edelrid Mega Jul is ranked 12th. Petzl grillon, camp druid, edelrid pinch (still getting evaluated for the standard) If you want the pulley then the CMC clutch. It will still work everywhere a GriGri 2 works, and that includes multi-pitch climbs. 5 - 10. Please read carefully before assuming anything because in no way did I say that the GriGri is "autolocking" or "hands free". On the GriGri you don't need a lot of force on the brake hand to cause it to lock so loosening your hand a bit to give slack is not a problem. Also have understood that Birdie is better at giving slack. Es heißt nun einfach „Grigri“. e feeding of different rope diameters) between the Grigri generations. A grigri is not sensitive to rope/carabiner choice, rope orientation to have the ABD actuate is a non issue with a grigri (and a significant issue with new climbers and ABD tubes). Jul 29, 2024 · The one caveat is that, unconsciously reverting back to my bad, old Grigri habits—taking my brake hand off to pinch the device open and reel out slack with the guide hand—has caused the Neox to lock up if my climber is pulling slack aggressively, giving the “click of death” that presages a potential short-roping. As others have stated, a grigri isn’t really meant for this sort of thing, however I have found with larger diameter ropes, such as 11. In seiner jüngsten Episode hat sich Ryan Jenks von HowNot2 mit Edelrid-Athlet Tommy Caldwell getroffen But then I don’t do heaps of tree work, mainly rope access, so I’m very familiar with this style of device. My options are Petzl GriGri (3) & Beal Birdie. GriGri seems like a "safe" choice but stainless steel construction of Birdie could be more durable. Grigri + und ob es sich lohnt, upzugraden oder als Neuling direkt das Neox anzuschaffen. There are many ways to correctly belay with each device depending on what your doing. You saying "I top rope with an ATC because I see OTHER PEOPLE who don't know how to belay with a GriGri properly" is nonsense - are you confident in your own Grigri for everything single pitch. All the other ones like click up, mammut smart, edelrid giga/mega Jul, BD ATC pilot etc. Mar 10, 2024 · I don't think I've used a lever to lower device since I used my mate's Eddy quite a lot but that's well over ten years ago. I’ll be interested to see the longevity of the pulley bearings in use…the grigri is bomb proof in this respect. The wheel on the Neox is too smooth, causing it to drop to the bottom of the belay loop and allowing rope to slip through after removing slack, even while hand over hand pulling through due to the lack of friction. Es war einmal… Jun 26, 2023 · Nach dem GRIGRI® und dem GRIGRI®+, die zu den Klassikern unter den Sicherungsgeräten mit Blockierfunktion geworden sind, hat Petzl nun ein weiteres Sicherungsgerät entwickelt: 2024 wird das NEOX® die Petzl-Sicherungsgeräte ergänzen. com Apr 21, 2025 · Lowering is rather different: then handle is more on-off than the grigri, so you have do more controlling with the brake hand. Bleibt zu guter Letzt noch die Frage nach den Unterschieden des Neox zum Grigri bzw. If you have left shoulder pains from paying out slack with your partner's unwashed dirty rope, then id highly recommend the Vergo as your main device. For sport cragging, the GriGri 2 is much more convenient to use. It’s different than an atc but easy to learn and the assisted breaking is nice. The grigri 2 is now at around $80 and the plus is about $140. If you stick to gym climbing the grigri 2 is the best bet especially for your money. The crimp, depending on how exactly you do it mainly uses your Flexor Digitorum Profundus. My advice is: Get a mammut smart, a petzl grigri, a beal birdie or whatever other assisted belay device you can find because with them you will be able to use with any carabiner and virtually any type of rope (8mm to 11mm) in any condition (Old or New) without having to worry if the device will actually work. It feeds rope easily enough that with a little practice you can belay the leader the same way you would with an ATC: no need to depress the camming action with your thumb. The PINCH is the first device on the market that can be attached directly to the central ring of the climbing harness. Jul 25, 2020 · Petzl GRIGRI+ and GRIGRI: Comparison Review. In the horrible event that your belayer was knocked out, and fortunately using a grigri. It's annoying to get used to, but it requires a controlled descent. I’ve never had an issue with the Mega Jul not being smooth. At $150, the NEOX tacks on an extra $40 to the GRIGRI, which is basically what you’re paying for a snag-free slack-paying experience. With the G+ that can be mitigated. Either one is great and “safe/secure” as far as belay devices go Mar 10, 2024 · Grigris and Grigri IIs don't have a panic mode for lowering, so I'd probably find the Pinch with it on annoying. I think only grigri + have a panic mode now, so lots of people will be used to using assisted belaying devices won't be used to a panic mode, hence why you can turn if off the Pinch presumably. This Oct 1, 2020 · It actually loads the same as a Grigri, only recommended to be mounted in reverse on the belay loop to takes advantage of the fact that on most harnesses, the belay loop is fairly stiff and doesn't twist very easily and thus provides additional friction for the Cinch/Vergo to lock more reliably when the load is upward. Multpitch: 1X Grigri + 1X ATC, or 2X ATC, depending on the situation. IIRC the passive assisted devices like the Jul weren’t around then either. An on-top prusik would not engage the cam of the grigri and will in fact serve as your primary. no moving parts on it, nothing to fail but the metal itself. Andy Kirkpatrick writes about how a Grigri can break a carabiner in a real-world scenario using examples of when it actually happened. When I started i got an ATC and I ended up buying a Grigri for sport climbing. Thanks to its low, close-to-the-body position, the PINCH does not need to be fixed in place when Sep 24, 2024 · The Neox is significantly heavier than a Grigri and even more so than any ATC. Dec 5, 2024 · Catch and Bite. Nov 29, 2022 · They work the same; the differences b/w the Birdie and Grigri are no different than the small variations in use (i. Feb 21, 2020 · Compared to the most popular active assist belay devices, it weighs twice as much and costs more. The strategy is: lead start, belayed by grigri. Even though it is tricky to switch over from a grigri, once you have the handling down, it is FAR smoother, and takes way less effort to use than the OG. Mar 20, 2025 · Only devices like the grigri, neox, pinch, eddy etc. The Eddy does have a few benefits over the standard GriGri: it's smoother with thick ropes (>10. One of my reasons for buying the Pinch is that the rope feeds from the front rather than the side while lowering, which in theory might kink the rope less. Second unties the knot and raps both strands on the other device, with partner giving fireman belay. These all all awesome features! But it's not a $40 difference. For rappelling, you can use it as a regular tube or with a brake like a GriGri - but it clamps on two ropes instead of one. Each weigh 179 grams) It can be used assisted brake, regular tube, guide mode tube. Maybe you're just buying the wrong used gear. Mar 10, 2024 · Grigris and Grigri IIs don't have a panic mode for lowering, so I'd probably find the Pinch with it on annoying. The GriGri 2 always locked up. Lowering on the grigri+ is more similar to the original grigri, but still has the two-stage can release to make life just that tiny bit miserable. Basically the Grigri can become loaded in such a way that fall force applies torque to the carabiner and the sheer force breaks the carabiner. Adventure Gear. But a used grigri from someone who got into top roping, decided it wasn't right for them, and promptly left the basically brand new device in a bin for a few years, sounds like a good deal for 40 bucks. Tre The click up is an excellent product, but I would absolutely recommend the GriGri to an amateur as it is more common. But for recreational sport climbing the GRIGRI has been brilliant and is a constant in my pack. Fewer items, packed into a single bag for ease of transport to make traveling simpler with more focus on the experience than the logistics. That is all when holding on to my personal favorite which allows both parties to set up and check each other is to set up the atc first, then attach the grigri below the atc. At quick glance The Grigri+ looks very similar to the standard Grigri but it does have a few additional features that sets it apart. I'm looking to buy my first belay device. . Toprope mode has a solid cam lock, as mentioned. I have used grigri, atc and rama (from singing rock). I always see the GriGri being compared to ATC-style belay devices and the GriGri being crowned as the safest device available for sport climbing. A Grigri is very easy to use, and its semiautomatic brake is really safe. The jury is still out, but the Rhino seems like a good bet so far. I used an ATC for a while and have recently purchased a Mad Rock Lifeguard. Maybe you misread what I asked. The Pinch is designed to work with ropes between 8. 1 Grigri and 1 Guide/Reverso/whatever per team. So, in my opinion a guide plate is best in these environments. It is very safe - IF you use it correctly. Also like the Grigri 2 better than the new Grigri model…. But this has nothing to do with whether the GriGri is safe or not and everything to do with the belayers. And for good reason: The GRIGRI was the first assisted-braking device and carries a proven track record. I have a Mega Jul and a GriGri, and will only use the GriGri for top rope as I dislike the way you have to feed out slack. you can rappel with it. There is still some friction on the line but by weighting the bottom of the rope you usually don’t need to manually pull it through. Jun 16, 2024 · However, I will probably end up using it because of the ease of paying out without adopting another hand position. The Pinch has grooves to assist braking with the loose strand. Mehr dazu findest Du hier: Grigri: Überblick, Vergleich & Test. This means that, in this configuration, it relies on a push button, an internal safety that won't allow it to unlock when cammed and We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. When using friction knots, it's imperative that the cord making the knot have a difference in diameter from the rope of at least 3mm. GriGri & GriGri+ Differences. If a belayer lets go of the brake strand during a fall, the Grigri will still lock up and catch the climber. He said, “The V groove straightened out the rope while lowering and rappelling,” with less kinking than a Grigri. Nov 11, 2023 · Petzl GriGri 2, Edelrid Mega Jul Sport, and DMM Pivot are probably your best bets out of the 22 options considered. But I wouldn’t recommend it as a permanent solution However, keep in mind that the traditional shortfalls of the grigri are also present and have been largely amplified through each iteration. For everything else, the Lifeguard is clearly superior. Es verbindet die Vorteile des Klassikers Grigri von Petzl mit dem zusätzlichen Sicherheitsfeature einer Panikbremse und gewährleistet flüssiges Seilausgeben selbst bei zügigem Klippvorgang. It is almost exactly the same as the grigri 2, just can handle a very slightly greater range of rope diameter. * So einfach ist die Sache allerdings nicht. I don't have a mega jul (kinda want one though), but I do have a mammut smart. They specifically recommend the use of Petzl Power Liquid, a silicone-based lubricant that is specifically designed for use with Petzl equipment. But it's much larger, heavier, and 4x the price. Jun 4, 2024 · Petzl changed the way climbers belay 33 years ago with its introduction of the GRIGRI, the world's first assisted-braking belay device. An ATC is more delicate as its proper use requieres more attention and experience. it doesn't pinch the rope like the grigri does. The only advantage of Birdie over GriGri is that it's easier to avoid that scenario all together (if you have a skinny rope) because the rope goes smoother when you apply the classic tube style of belaying. You should be competent and familiar with it, because someone will hand you one at some point. seminar where the main instructor indicated that he is comfortable using the ATC in guide-mode without always having a hand on the brake-side of the rope because when used that way, it is an "auto-locking device. However, when I look up comparisons between assisted breaking devices, they usually aren't compared in terms of safety, but in terms of convenience, ease of paying out rope, weight etc. Jun 13, 2018 · The GriGri + had a mediocre score in this category. I just hate it when I see someone treating the gri as a failproof device and using it incorrectly. Top roping was ass. The manufacturer of the Grigri, Petzl, recommends using a silicone-based lubricant for their assisted-braking belay devices like the Grigri. Posted by u/betapleatedsheets - 3 votes and 21 comments What's the Difference between NEOX and GriGri?Head to https://brilliant. An assisted belay device ideal for lead belaying with super slick rope feeding and au Getting my first assisted belay device - looking for opinions on these two. The Beal Birdie was self admitted by Beal to be a grigri copy and to compete on price point to get any market share. And it isn't bad. 5mm, it can still work fine in a pinch. Jun 18, 2024 · Petzl Neox vs. 0mm), more durable, and features an anti-panic lowering mechanism. Posted by Holly K on Saturday, July 25, 2020 in theDIHEDRAL Gear Reviews. If I’m spending a long day climbing, I will generally use the trick where you put a carabiner with a small nose through the back, and pull on that to lower. For rappels fix the rope in the middle, first person rappels with Grigri on single strand. Older Post Electric Cooler Review: SetPower vs Dometic. Obviously, this doesn’t mean the belayer should be careless with their brake hand, but it does mean that in the event the belayer screws up (through negligence or an unfortunate accident such as a rock falling Jan 5, 2025 · PINCH vs GRIGRI - The pinch slips at a higher force on skinny ropes but lower forces on fatter ropes compared to the grigri. A new Grigri like device from Edelrid with an interesting extra feature or two, but one in particular that makes me nervous. I should have warned her, especially because I saw someone do this at the crag like 3 weeks ago. Edit: the grigri + has a safety feature that if someone pulls the lever back all the way (which would drop the climber) it automatically locks as well. You won't have a good feel for it We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. I wouldn't say I've used it long enough, or often enough with Aug 13, 2024 · The structure and mechanics of the Edelrid Pinch are similar to the Petzl GRIGRI, giving a similar feel. Had a GriGri 1, which I found too heavy for multipitch climbing. My inner mathematician got SO excited when Petzl suggested that I do (as a follow-up to my GRIGRI 2 review) a comparison review of the GRIGRI+ and the new GRIGRI (the third one). While you can control the speed carefully with the lever, big weight differences and/or skinny/wet ropes can make it more like a full on/off release. May 16, 2024 · Not surprisingly, it's much quieter! Additionally: Due to the long channel for the bridge the device is aligned rock solid with the handle to the left and the braking strand to the right. Das alte funktioniert doch seit einigen Jahren. I like this more than to the side of the device (facing the climber) like the GriGri. actually qualify as assisted braking devices (can hold a high fall factor fall with no hands on braking rope EN15151-1). Don't do that. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. are (mis?)sold as assisted braking devices but only pass the manual braking device Jerky lowering off a GriGri suggests to me that you're relying on primarily the lever to control speed. Once someone is proficient with both an ATC and a GriGri2, I think the case is difficult to make that the ATC is any safer. Therefore I wanted to know more. 8mm. llooltcntojtydtesrvstvvspbvlzpbdfxfjqjdelkpbwz