Marines vs army reddit. Many soldiers primary duty is whatever desk job they have.

Marines vs army reddit Marine Recruiter here I tell all the young man and women I talk to everyday. Pilots in AF vs. The Marines and the Army Infantry are absolutely no different in regards to what you learn and how you train. Now regarding Marine vs Army, I can tell you right now if you’re not 100% set on becoming a Marine officer first, then absolutely go Army. That's not to mention all the raw material and logistical support that barely kept the Red Army going. I would argue the commando tests are quite a bit harder. If we go to war somewhere the RMR will mobilise for sure (they slot into regular formations on tour). We have Army units that do mostly the same thing, but usually dropped by air. Army and/or Marines aren't always allowing prior service to join. The Army is significantly larger than the Marine Corps. It did not happen that way though, the Iraqis did not waste manpower on the Marine advance, instead the Iraqis did something extremely intelligent: they waited for the Army to pass and then attacked the weaker National Guard The doctrine is different from Army too. If they had sufficient prep time, were able to channel the orcs, had high ground, about 2km of distance, had two grenadiers, two heavy gunners, a sniper, and a Carl-G (this is a standard 12 marine rifle squad complement), they could probably hold out for a little while- but 10 vs 10,000 is going to be a pretty big problem. The Marines tend to be a heavier force since they bring more armored vehicles with them. And the army can be as weird as the Corps is for field days, but for huge over the top morning PT sessions insanely early. Magic" has been done well around here many times. While the Marines were being attacked, Army was going to disappear into the desert, drive all night, and show up in Karbala to attack Baghdad. They have Harriers; the USAF has Thunderbolts. Army needs to capitalize on the fact that they have a ton of diverse career fields (especially compared to Marines) and that they have the badass aspects Marine units are organized into Marine Air-Ground Task Forces (MAGTFs), combining air, ground, and logistics elements. wow. If you want to be special operations than do your time in the Marines and join the Raiders. The Army also has lots and lots of Soldiers who flat out don’t care and just try to make basic minimums because it’s just After a fun debate with some friends I wanted to see what Reddit thought. i’m worried about advice that people have given to me about career prospects after the marines and what i can gain from the marines vs what i can gain from the army. The Army has a sizeable special operations pipeline that recruits and trains quality people and provides opportunities that that Marines don’t have. The difference now, is that the every Royal Marine becomes a Royal Marine Commando but not every USMC becomes a Marine Raider. Physical Activity is a escape from my mind. I too am an RO. The Army was a bigger part of the Iraq surge than the Marines were, #'s wise, and operated in most parts of the country including Al Anbar. If you’re looking for military training and to be and officer with an actual college experience on the side I would heavily recommend NROTC. Explore the unique roles these elite US military branches play in national defense. The Marines will not help you. I am currently trying to decide if I should join the Army or the Navy, and It would be much appreciated if I could hear from you about what you think I should do. The Army had more of a presence in the war, as being a larger branch they fought in all 4 Corps of the country, so you could choose any number of the army division that were Earning the title of Marine definitely means something. Marine OCS is a 6 week course NROTC marine cadets do their Junior year, so it’s closer to Army Advanced Camp (which all AROTC Cadets have to do). So if the US has an embassy to a country, you could end up going there. I know that it is more likely to be successful when applying to be an Army officer just based on the number of spaces per year. Where in Army it feel like separate organization between the MOS and units. Even historically speaking the US Rangers are closer in lineage given they were mostly formatted after Army Commandos (defacto what the RM fulfil the role of now bar a few exceptions) and if we defer to actions on D-Day, Point Du Hoc and the RM actions in Port En Bessin are more comparable than what the US Marines were doing I wanted infantry but I wasn't sure whether I should join the army or marines. And I've heard the phrase "Jarhead of the Army" when describing Rangers. Army, it's reversed. With Renegade Primarchs like Magnus the Marines have a chance. 16 votes, 58 comments. If you're agnostic, go Army--a lot more opportunities out there. No nukes, the US supplies its Navy and Marines while Iran and Russia help supply China with resources. A sub for anyone to ask questions about the military. You just won't be doing it with an EGA. in the lore they do it a lot more. Then I realized how shitty the amenities are, and the Army offered more opportunities for me. As for Army vs Marines, you're going to get different answers depending on people's experiences with both branches. Guard vs. Roboute Guilliman could beat a drunk Spiderman but would lose to 30 clones of Batman. The marines can stay in a a singe position and mow down the legion as they advance with their primative technologies. This is often not an easy transition. Marine Corps Officer . Army being the largest branch is comparable to working retail, but at walmart. Apparently there were over 3 million soldiers on each side and several thousand artillery, aircraft, and tanks. I believe this is done on purpose so when (if) you deploy you can cope with the REAL stress a little better. I dont regret the army but I tell people to join the airforce because 20 years is much more doable the army marines or navy. The US decides to stop China before they become too powerful of a superpower. True, the US Navy is the most important at projecting US power across the world, and has the 2nd largest Airforce in the world but they and the Marines have far fewer troops than the US Army and US Airforce. It’s up to you. All that 4 years of the infantry will do is teach you skill the army will teach you as well as possibly hurt your joints before even getting a shot at something like RASP. Also, ignore the fact the the US has the Air Force as its own air force, but so does the US Navy and US Marines. However, the Marine Corps has an unfair advantage in this competition. If you want to do any sort of civil engineering stuff I would recommend Navy, Air Force, or Army over Marines. Both Rangers and Seals are absolute professionals and it a squad vs squad situation the conflict could swing to either side. I was in Anbar in 2004, and I was in a Marine battalion attached to an Army brigade which was attached to a Marine division. The whole, once a marine always a marine thing. If you want Army go Army. Im coming from being an infantry rifleman. " In the army, you can do everything a marine does plus a bunch of other shit. Requirements for marines is that you are an NCO, up on reenlistment, and utilize this for your lat move, have a 110 GT score or higher, be eligible for top secret clearance, take the tabe test and score an 11 or higher, get recommended by your plt sgt, plt co, 1st sgt, and company co. And the US Army has Open ground warfare vs ranked marines is a bad place for an assassin to be, however if they're on the hunt they will only engage when they have the upper hand. I am going to assume the Marines are in addition to the French and British soldiers not instead of. A more interesting question would be the One Piece Marines vs a much higher tech military, like the Halo verse. May be a dumb question, so sorry in advance. I am a very hands on, active, on the ground woman. Slightly related combat story. Your best bet would be to toss some messages on the Army and USMC reddit. Didn’t have to worry about that in army barracks. I hear living quarters can be better and they have faster promotions. They have Hornets; so does the Navy. The Marine version of OCC is 10 weeks which is closer to the Army’s longer 12 week OCS. China, for instance, calls its entire military the People's Liberation Army. Don’t really have a specific interest in what MOS I want to do. well. They have ground forces; so does the Army. WTF is up with this? Out of curiousity, what are your guy's thoughts on this? Archived post Also, commando tests and 36 weeks training vs 8 tests and 30 weeks training. Exactly this. Ask this exact same question about the US Army and US Marines and you’ll get just as confusing answers. you've never served. The Marines are impressed with themselves in the same way that the Army Airborne is impressed with themselves. Marine DIs can't do that. I want to be in either the 75th ranger regiment or be a Reconnaissance Marine, my shape is okay as of now but I’ve lost 70 pounds so far and keep going until next summer. They are both SoF elements. UNSC Marines vs UNSC Army . Many soldiers primary duty is whatever desk job they have. Whether the Marine Corp produces a better trained product is a matter of conjecture and not based off any clear cut verifiable The Kwantung Army’s 1939 defeat at Kholkin Gol (vs the Soviets) is a great example of the kinds of problems the IJA would have versus the US Marines. I think Marines are roughly equivalent to the Army Rangers. I originally wanted to join the Marines because the advertising made them look dope. You get to say you’re a Marine for the rest of your life. He watched the entire marine unit open up and shoot everything in sight. Reddit isn't going to answer the question comprehensively. You might be able to change branches down the line but it is not a guarantee. The Marine Corps holds higher standards in general than the army but it really depends on the culture and job that you want to do in the military. From what I can tell, your initial contract is longer but because you commission immediately (rather than doing basic, and then waiting for your OCS class to begin) your total term of Marines were usually lighter equipped and armed, and relied upon impudence and aggression to penetrate deep and then hold while the Army caught up. And I love it. He’s considering Army vs Royal Marines, Advice I want to join the military as an office and have been considering both the army and the Royal Marines I was wondering if anyone could give some extra back ground on how the royal marine office training course works and what it entails. Coast guard is good option too if you like being by the water We don’t need two armies. The 82nd Airborne definitely appeals to me. Even if the marines get spotted, they are small enough of a force to move and not be spotted, while the legion cannot do the same. Im a marine in the barracks and I know the living conditions in the Barracks here in Cherry Point NC ain’t “that” bad but compared to the air force it could be Earning the title of Marine definitely means something. The culture of the Army, especially aviation is MUCH more relaxed. If there was an all out war between these three groups, who would down a whole emperor’s crew each, which is absolutely not happening. 10/10 in my book Cons: Work life - no one does their job you're always doing other tasks, going to the field for 3 months, or doing a detail that doesn't even slightly involve your mos. Navy Seals are Special Forces. Army Basic Training . Sure, we poked fun at each other ("Army is a bunch of pussies," "Marines are a bunch of retards"), but branch rivalry. I’m/was leaning toward the army heavily but now but after going to a marine corps group pt I loved the camaraderie. Should have stayed army. USMC had Marine Raiders and RM has Royal Marine Commandos. Te army takes a man and makes them a soldier. Earning the title Marine truly feels special, the connection to our History and Culture in the Marine Coprs is unmatched by any of the other branches. Chad and its expanded universe. Do both the Marines and Army have similar training, or do they both have different training? Reddit's home for all things Halo, the franchise developed by 343 Industries and previously developed by Bungie. (Rant Warning) But for Army you would of had Airborne (not special forces but still cool AF), Green beret or Ranger. The US has the largest marine corps by number of active soldiers. I don’t recommend the other way around, because you’ll most likely lose rank going from Army to USMC AND you’ll have to go through USMC bootcamp where as you don’t have to go to Army boot camp if you had doneUSMC first. During peace time in the late 1800’s having a force to protect US interests was important, without an army the Marines were always available since they were part of the Navy. Some of those Army guys are fat as fuck and anytime I worked with the Army many of them Marines actually have higher standards for written entrance exam scores than the army, not sure about navy and air force. For those who have been in both, what are the notable differences? Archived post. But Army Navy and Air Force have to complete Marine basic to join the Marines. It's all based on your branch and your unit. You won't really gain anything going from one to the other. The Army, Navy, Marines, Airforce, and Coast guard (plus reserves for each branch). Usmc contracts for infantry are 5 and 6 years only. But if you young and single you can have a lot of fun in the army but it's much harder to do 20 years. I met with the marine corps, navy, and army. The 35F school in the Army is 4-5 months and takes place in Fort Huachuca, AZ. The Marines are the specialized amphibious fighters the Navy can and will deploy. An book about it—look up Major Scott Gress at Amazon. The Army appears to be a larger branch than the Marines, and we can infer that the Marines have a higher density of combat MOSs, likely even more than the US Marines. The Marine Corp’s culture is so vastly different than any other branch. Slow your roll with this one. China has the largest army by number of active soldiers. Army's premier light infantry unit, with specialized skills that enable the Regiment to perform a variety of missions. Going marine first and army second usually only happens when marines want to go national guard. Overall about 22 regular Army divisions served in There are army units as bad as the Corps units, if not worse. I find more interest in researching the Army than the Marines. Same shit, different areas of operation. I've been planning on joining the military for a year or two now through OCS after I graduate from college in 2020. I think the modern Marines come from a quirk in the US constitution which says the US must always maintain a Navy but only in times of war the US may raise an Army. What's the similarities and differences of marine and army culture?? I only plan to spend 4 years in the military, so I'd like to make it an enjoyable experience instead of a lifetime career type thing. My opinion: NCOs and junior officers in the Marines are just better all around leaders and are tactically more proficient. Army: In garrison you will have an artificially high stress level. In the army riflemen are mostly guys who can't qualify as anything else, which leads to them being disparaged. Marine OCS is not Army OCS. You go to basic, then WOCS, then onto flight school with maybe a month or two of prep courses in between. We don’t need 180,000 Marines any more than we need Army Airborne to go form its own 180,000 “United States Airborne Corps” branch. in reality, there shouldn't be a comparison. The Army of the Dead gets their full number of wights, has the NK, the Walkers and the Ice Dragon. Similarly, air force PJs and CCTs have an insanely hard training, while Army medic I've heard is a big party after a few weeks. Marine DIs stay doing that shit. Recon isn’t bad and is evolving and will hopefully end up in a goos place soon. But not quite to the level of SOC. The problem is that it's not your full-time Marine Corps job; rather, it's a "b-billet" that you can volunteer for, go do for three years, then return to your old job. which is fine btw. Some background - I'm a 21 year old senior at a top 50 university with a 3. Marines have a great thing going. I love working out. In terms of equipment Marine infantry is getting some cool stuff it seems. No service branch is more “honorable” than any others. To see it in another aspect, lets compare the Marines to the Army. The general advice with the Marines, of course, is to only do Marines if that is what you really, really want to do. however after 2 combat deployments to somalia and bosnia (yes I'm that old), i can find this img very amusing. I never graduated bct after an injury (stress fracture then hernia). I'm currently still trying to decide between Army and Marines (my goal is to be an infantry officer for ~5 years), mostly because, though I started out wanting to go Army, I've met so many successful people Army will give you a bonus most likely to sign on. Compare the US Marine Corps and US Army: discover the differences in mission, training, and culture. Though my brother and I were Marines, my father was Army artillery during Korea. Understand the distinct histories, values, and requirements of the Marines and Army, and which path may be right for you. S millitary consists of different branches. I hear shit being tossed around ALL the time about how marine BC makes Army BT look like a cake walk. There's a saying in the Marines that every Marine is a rifleman first. Modern weapons are so effective that skill of the user comes into play a lot less than in prior warfare. So why have the latter at all? Is it because marines are trained for landing Would love if theres anyone who’s went marine to army to help out and answer!! I joined this Reddit page to ask a few questions and advice those already in the army or marines. Army infantry vs Marine infantry, probably not much difference. If you go marines then look into force recon. To me. Virgin vs. Hazing (smoking), making people stay until 7 for no reason. I am seriously contemplating making the military a career and have realized the Army provides superior career advancement over the Marines. Log In / Sign Up; Advertise on Reddit; Shop Collectible Avatars; Marine Reserves vs Army Reserves . Marines are the only force that fully integrate infantry, armor (pre-2021), artillery, logistics, fixed and rotary wing aviation into a tactical fight, through the MAGTF concept. Whether I am missing something entirely and being retarded in my judgement, or not, I would like to hear you guys thoughts on the difference of the Marines and Army. S Army National I am slightly pulled towards being a marine reservist due to the opportunity of global deployments and also they work more towards coastlines which is an interest of mine- but the Army or marine infantry They're the part of the Marine Corps tasked with guarding US diplomatic missions arpund the world. " source. Theres squared away grunts and shitbag grunts in both. It'd be tough to compare high tech weaponry vs. Basically, the US Army is like the UK Army, all broken up into smaller cultures. various unit cultures, bro. And some of the army barracks are just as bad the Marine ones. I still sometimes think about how my life could've been different if I'd stuck with the SEAL contract, or if I knew about Navy or Army EOD, but I can say I don't regret my time as a Marine one bit. And the marines have unlimited ammunition no So 300 Space Marines equip only with Spartan arms and armor are holding the Hot Gates vs the Persian Army. Every other non combat arms MOS, the Marines just flat out have a higher troop quality. I joing the Military get into SOF. I think some of the stereotype comes from their "every man a rifleman" ethic. It’s not that hard for a youngster to get into the Rangers, but it can be very hard to stay there. Just want to lead other Marines and have other Marine leaders push me. It’s almost cult like. Ranger School is brutally hard. They have their own Medics, their own bases, etc. I would dispute the claim that Marines occupy areas after Army cleans them out. ***Please use a clear title for your question I want to join the marines but I’m not sure if I’m fit enough I’m 5’8 and 183 pounds I know no matter what branch I do want to do infantry for the marines either machine gunner or anti tank missleman and just basic infantry for the army my family thinks I wouldn’t be good in the marines because I’ve always been in their opinion too nice and expected me to be like my dad and go View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. He’s in an intelligence MOS. Marines are the first on the ground in any situation so if you want to be in the crux of the shit when it hits the fan, Marines is where you want to be. I'm guessing it is easier in the Army than the Marines, but you shouldn't count on being able to make that switch. the army or the Marines your the one that is gonna have live that life I’ve heard that Royal Marines Officer training is more focused on turning you into a Marine whereas Army Officer training is specifically about turning you into an Officer and a leader. Questions about joining the US Air Force and Space Force, whether enlisting or commissioning “The Army has a higher ceiling and a lower floor than the Marines. But every Marine knows that Rangers are the real tip of the spear. He then kills the entire army as he shreds through them like a lightning bolt, taking no damage at all and barely exerting himself. You can "travel the world" in all branches; if you join the Marines there's a chance you get stuck on a ship anyway; there's bonding and camaraderie and people you get annoyed at in every branch. It would take exactly 26 and a half Imperium psykers or United States Army on Reddit Members Online • [deleted] ADMIN MOD Marine Boot camp vs. Don't ignore the recruiting methods used by Army v/s Marines. The key difference is in mission set and getting specific jobs in the infantry. I don’t care which one stays or goes—we could have a 500,000 man Marine Corps and a 100,000 man Army or vice versa. Army: Traditionally fights on land, but also has planes and such for transport. Sure, the Soviet army was much bigger at 6 million vs. The Marine will take a lot with him, but he's not beating a thousand dudes. I've know a couple prior service guys who switched from marines to army and despite all of the army bs, it was still far better than the marines in their opinions. Even with Renegade Space Marines and the Deathwatch it is still not enough. What made me interested in the marines instead of the army was the difficulty levels. The important difference between the Army and the Marines is how they are organized. Tldr: help me pick between Army Navy and Airforce. View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit. Games workshop always said that the marines in the game are massively nerfed from what they are like in universe otherwise in a game it would be 1 marine vs an army. g. The Army has a much larger pool of MOS’s/Jobs though. Marine rifle or weapons platoons would also have one or more Navy hospital corpsmen assigned along with the Marines. Marine Corps Reserves Infantry V. Hi everyone, I (19M) am joining the military as soon as I can. And tbh, the Army better programs for ppl to get potential candidates into the SOF world. Despite Marines being vaunted for their marksmanship, the Army produces the best shooters in the entire military and world. So they send their Navy and Marines with the objective of gaining complete Sea and Air supremacy over China in 5 years. The Marines are in fact a second Army, and since they compete with the Army for funds, missions, and prestige, their real enemy is the US Army. Again—rivalry aside. I was a Cav Scout in the Army and really wanted to 1 over arching culture vs. you don't call the Army do do strategic bombing; that's the Air Force's business. The Rangers is something completely different. Get app Get the Reddit app Log In Log in to Reddit. . I'm lazy and it's easier to However it seems significantly more straightforward to commission as a Marine; No basic training, easier to get your desired MOS, Marine OSO’s are far more responsive than army recruiters. But Marines get treated damn near the same in the end and the pride of being a Marine is way more appealing than joining the Army like everyone else. promotion system - yeah army/marines really did good one this one. And foundationally, Marines are going to have an edge going into S of I, given that they receive measurably more shooting, small unit combat skills at basic than Army (non-infantry pipeline) recruits do. And often in Iraq and Afghanistan, Marines and Army held down totally different regions. We deployed to the same places, shot the same weapons, kicked in the same doors, etc. You're young so if I were you I'd pick army. 0 coins. The alliance wins and crushes the WG. Marines: Similar to the Army, but paired with the navy for transport and is used to rapidly respond to things. Advertisement Coins. The Corps is the worlds biggest frat, it's far, far, far more of a brotherhood than being in the Army is. the US army's 2 million, but like I said, that's 6 million mouths they'd be unable to feed. Marines is a bit longer overall but I don’t think there’s much infantry The marines are more about exercising and push you harder than the army, but the army is more bearable for some when it comes to that, and the mental pushing is also different I’ve been planning on joining the Marines because I really respect their strong ethos, the amphibious nature of their operations, and the sharp Comparing Marines and Army missions, training, structure, and culture. u/Schaftenheimen has previously answered Why was the United States Marine Corps such a small military branch before 1941?. The 75th Ranger Regiment is the U. The Marine Corp doesn't have a monopoly on infantry training or skills or tactics no more than the Army does. First question is does the army have the same camaraderie as the USMC. Don’t waste a Marine Recruiters time, go waste someone else’s. At first I wanted to go AF, but after thinking. Army has soldiers but not fixed wing aviation, Navy has Space marines are fast, they aren’t that fast. Short version: Recon Marines are usually in a reconnaissance unit for a Marine division and perform actions to support that division's mission. If you're in the Army reserves and want to get your hands dirty it'll be easier to transfer to Army reserve units that are busy I would go Marines, because I'm joining the Marines. However Ranger school is not the same as being a Ranger in the 75th Ranger Reg which is the SOCOM unit that stacks bodies. What are the main differences between life in the reserves of the Army vs Marines? People tell me don’t go Marines because of toxic leadership, being treated like less than human, etc but I didn’t know if you still had to deal with that in the reserves or if it’s a bit better. Which Branch? I am wanting to join the reserves but can’t figure out which branch. Learn about the unique roles of each branch, including combat, peacekeeping, and humanitarian efforts. Not as common with 0311 but we send recon Marines every year for sure . so it'd be easy to compare Marines vs other branches. Army Officer vs. Marines are taught history which instills pride. Marines are the few, the proud. We talked and I’ve come to the conclusion that I’m going to enlist in the Marines as infantry mos, get some tougher training off the bat compared to Army and then if I’m still set on Army ranger I will move into the Army after my service with the USMC. To get better equipment and gear, as well as participate meaningfully in this scenario, they need to build some kind of better alternative to Rome. When people say the Marine Corps is not for everybody, they absolutely mean it. They're similar story to Royal Marines Commandos. Even the navy falls under it. But if you want a super specific job, go Army. 5+ gpa in a STEM major. An Army Infantryman is probably going to have a rougher IET than a cook for the marines. The Marines have invested decades of effort into structuring an image and a brand recognition that appeals to young men (mostly) who want a challenge. Also I note there are plenty of times Marines go to a country and Army (or Navy) doesn't and vice versa. WTF are you even talking about? Not really. You can go to Ranger school as a Marine . Size and Composition. Part of it is marketing. nobody compares the Army to the Navy. Unless you want to earn the title of Marine, go Army. Discipline. The marines Range, and fire rate would be too great for the legion to handle. The Marines and the Army fought side by side in the Pacific theater, many of the famous battles fought by the Marines had Army units present, the Campaign Book for Marianas and Pelelu actually give theater selectors for Army in the Pacific while the main US Army gives none! The Marines never fought in the European theater, other than literally And the final war arc will begin. The Marines fought courageously at the Battle of Belleau Wood, but it was ultimately the US Army’s 26th division that liberated the village after the Marines had already left. Picture the Marines and Army, two pillars of American military might with their storied histories and distinct battle cries. We just don’t. As a private you would wake up at about 5:30, your team leader knocking on your door. I was thinking Army and Marines would best fit me but I would like some outside help/information of what would be the best. Army and Marine units fought together on Guadalcanal. Posted this in r/Militaryfaq a while ago but didn't get any replies: . But we don’t need two. Can the space marines hold them? Bonus round, the Persian's find the path to flank them, do the Astarties Dine in Hell that night or Not USMC but more like Marine Raiders. The Marines thought the Army was cowardly in how slow it operated, and the Army thought the Marines were reckless and apathetic towards loss of life. Dig into this read to understand what sets these forces apart—from their inception during America’s fight for The army fights on land, and so do many countries' marines. But, as a broad statement (not counting SOF,) the Marine Corps will probably offer you the most stereotypical military experience. It does happen active duty, just not as often as guard. I wanted something that was going to challenge me further than anything has ever done before. United States Army on Reddit Members Online Honest opinions of Army Vs Navy Vs Airforce . They fired 155mm Long Toms. I hear it's much more common for a Marine to join the Army than it is for a soldier to join the Corps. I've always sorta leaned toward the aggressive-type culture of the marines, but I've never questioned or heard about the culture of the Army. Edit: I’m not talking about the culture either, like marines vs army rivalry, but the job today. Reasons Why the Army Appeals to Me: I enjoy firing weapons I like going on walks/hikes The physical challenges it presents I like camping if I am with some buddies The Marines could do it but it is debatable on how likely they are to succeed. Your insinuation that Marine infantry somehow does different things than Army infantry, or that we "24/7 live in that shit" and they don't, tells me you've probably done neither. The army doesn’t offer group pt to the poolees. Bonus: Marines kill the Emperor, Guard kills Marines. Round 2: I still think the Guard stomps, except Vulkan who is immortal. like you all go to different bootcamps, etc. I was also in during war time and got deployed. Each has its own mission and standard operating Army is 22 weeks of infantry OSUT and Marines is 13 weeks of boot camp plus 14 weeks of infantry school. Space marines win vs real world humans, but the master chief and the spartans would put up a decent match. A more apt comparison might be the Army’s regular light infantry divisions, like the 82nd or 101st. Devil Fruit magic, but I'm sure "Tech vs. The downside to the Marines though is that you can't necessarily pick your MOS. Marines: Large numbers of regular troops who can show up quickly, often by sea, to fight. So yeah in my personal case they were basically identical in role, though overall Anbar province was heavily Marine while I'm currently doing the lat-move over to eod. Navy vs. 30K subscribers in the AirForceRecruits community. The rest is history. u/when_ducks_attack has previously explained the role of the Marines in Europe (scroll down for the follow-up answers, this answer is less than six months old) . I'm also a personal trainer and fraternity president. But my weakness is im a little boneheaded. Don't give in to the "First to Fight" Army attitude or the "If you ain't a Marine, you ain't shit" Marine attitude. Your current command has to release you, and you have to be accepted into active duty. I transferred from the RMR to the int corps reserves because I wanted to do more than just training exercises. Probably also argue that the Marines are generally a nicer and smarter bunch, the paras I’ve met tend Space Marines get one-shot by bolters more often than not which have similar yields to grenade launchers. Also, pick a job that transfers well to the civilian sector- 25, 68, 35 Other key differences: Factual: Army org has everyone about a paygrade higher than their Marine counterpart (squad leaders are SSgt which is a platoon sergeant in the Marines, Army platoon Sergeants are Sergeant First Class). And the Army has helicopters and some small planes, but legally can’t have its own air force. Army is land based warfare, navy is water based, Air Force is air based, and marines are for maritime fighting. Since the end of Desert Storm the US Army has been downsized by one third, losing over 200,000 troops and eight combat divisions. Army is typically used as larger force groups on the ground level (e. And the liberation of the Philippines was primarily an Army operation, mainly because the Philippines with their large islands were much better suited to the Army than the Marines. Tank I was leaning towards the marines but at the same time a lot people I hear and I've talked to said army is better for lifestyle and career wise. 57K subscribers in the Militaryfaq community. However, after doing research, I found that the Army's infantry schools and opportunities offer more avenues for growth. It's quite frequently the total reverse. Should I join the army or the marines. During World War 2 both USMC and Royal Marines had a specialist unit. You could do an enlistment in the Corps then go Army. S. Army Rangers are more dedicated to the job of being a soldier than the average soldier. That or as Talos from the Night Lords would say: the 40k Astartes are thin bloods and pale in comparison to their forbears. In some countries, marines are part of the army. Personally I am going to try for Marsoc but if I don’t get it, no sweat my contract ends next year so I can switch to army and go Air borne. He said they took contact from a village at night. Difficulty and skill wise line infantry units in both the army and marines are pretty similar. Meanwhile, u/DBHT14 has addressed the role of the US Army in the Pacific (again, less than I’ve been set on the army rangers for a while but was recently approached by a USMC recruiter. Once you complete Marine Corps basic training later in your career if you need to switch branches you do not have to repeat basic training. Expand user menu Open settings menu. 3 mile run vs 2 miles. Note that the Marines got rid of their tanks, though. They get to man the wall (tho they are stretched all along it) and bring all hand-held and light stationary weapons avaliable to them. In the Army, if you have a pulse and don’t give up you will make it through flight school. Army might still offer 4 year contracts. Space Marines are made up of rag-tag squads of Ultramarines and Imperial Fists. So you have that in Marines but the understanding at the end of day we are Marines Grunt or POG. US Army sergeant arrested in alleged murder-for 187K subscribers in the virginvschad community. 100 space marines seem to be able to conquer entire planets in some books, but absent plot armor and the power of the ship they arrive on, how do you think the modern American military would fair vs 100 space marines and associated support equipment. Out of 1000 marines, I am pretty sure more than a few of them will have access to grenade launchers, RPGs, and the like. Pirates vs Marines vs The Revolutionary Army . How does the role of an Army Infantry Platoon Commander compare I’m having a hard time picking the marines or the army, I know the ups and downs of each with a lot of downs for the marines I know. In short, my Army experience was harder physically than Marine boot. In the Army you’ll still “earn the title” of Soldier, Infantryman, and Paratrooper. Where as the Marines are a fighting force that are attached to the Navy. During the battle of White Horse Mountain (actually one of the biggest battles during Korea, much after Chosin - where our history seems to stop) the Army set records for sustained fire that still stand. as would the Marines and soldiers i served with (yes, they would find I served in both the Marines and Army. Army Rangers vs Marine Infantry So the 75th Ranger Regiment is known for hazing their new guys. Army units were taking territory in Iraq during the invasion at the same time Marines were doing it. When it comes to intelligence disciplines, my favorite is counterintelligence, HUMINT, and GEOINT. I discovered to the army identities not a group as a whole organization like in the Marine Corps. My army recruiter was a former marine and he laid it out like this "The army can give you whatever you want, except for being a marine. Long version: I originally joined the army back in 2008ish. Specifically to Halo, the Marines have to be very adaptable, since they don’t know what their I’m just finishing my last year of university and am aiming to become either an Army Infantry officer or a Royal Marines officer. Normal infantry Marines (rivalry aside) are light infantry, and more akin strategically to Army light infantry. If we base this battle on Matt ward: The space marine crosses the 200 meters before the humans can even react, because he moves like a blur of light. Going off what the OP wrote, No weapons supply chain, what each unit has when the War begins is what they have to get the job done, The US Navy wouldn't get that Got it. I'm not in the marines and I've never met an active duty recon marine before. They also have that weird obsession with the IT sand pits. Your rank will carry over. Both are good options then. There is a 10 year ADSO now after flight school, VS the Marines have an 8 year ADSO. I slept outside in the snow and ice been through so The U. The Army is a fluid, 100% self contained branch. All you have to do is look back at the invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq. To my understanding it's not a comparable role. My best friend is an officer in the Army, and he loves it. R1) So much of the question comes down to the USMC doing something they don't: Nation Building. The IJA’s force at that battle was far more numerous, but the Soviets has a lot more artillery, armor and air support, and they were a lot better at using those assets in a coordinated manner. I miss the Marines, but the army lifestyle was a better fit for me. My experience is with 35F in the Army so I'll give you my perspective of that. Six months late, but no way I, as a soldier in the Army, would tell someone in the Air Force (who's not an aircraft mechanic) that we in the Army have it better at all. in the game marine bolters have always been able to penetrate the armour of light vehicles like rhino's, speeders , chimeras etc . Marine Corps has more discipline and esprit de corp in general, but you will see similar levels of fitness, training, discipline, and skill between a Marine unit and an Army airborne unit. Someone in the Air Force, who isn't a mechanic, should be glad as hell that they are in the Air Force, instead of If you want to be a Ranger join the army. Army recruiting focuses on benefits and career opportunities and a sprinkle of adventure. What exactly an army does is dependent upon the country. If you have to second guess between Marines or Army or any other branch for that matter Just go Army and get out of my way, the Marines is not for you. Atm I'd go Army for an easier life but I didn't care about that so I went Marines and I'm loving it because I knew what to expect If your heart says Navy then by all means go Navy, nobody can make the ultimate decision except for you. Army I have been interested in becoming a pilot for a long time and now that I'm nearly done with my college career (one year left) I am starting to seriously consider what I want to do. While Rangers are light infantry, they’re still Special Operations Forces, a league beyond regular infantry. i cant decide on if i want to enlist in the army or marines but the main thing i am looking for is the one i can do college in. The Marine Corps usually works in smaller units than the army does and has alot more focus on raids off of navy ships. In the Marines, I had to sit in a sweaty laundry room for hours to make sure some piece of shit didn’t throw my clothes out of the wash/dryer, or straight up steal them. Meanwhile the Army boys turned on their PEQs and started to identify their targets and pick then off bit by bit. Honestly just a squad of standard Marine or Army infantry would stand a decent shot of winning this type conflict. Thays about the closest thing to ranger I can think of for them. I don't think it matters branch as much as specific job. “All USMC officers need to go through OCS“ is misleading. I’m 100% sure that every marine ever would disagree with that. But being a Paratrooper is pretty cool too. Army didn't care where you were Finally, Army didn't converge on you and yell necessarily as much as Marine DIs past Red phase. I left the Marines because long term the army provided more promotions and had a better quality of life standard than the Marines could afford. So yeah, Marine Infantry are like a wrecking ball, Army Infantry are like a sledgehammer Swimming, Shooting, Drill. Also the Marines tear you down and build you into a Marine. Round 3: Marines get roflstomped. If lend lease gets shut off, the Soviet army would starve to death in like a month. Members Online. And that's in a regular platoon. We don’t know much about the revolutionary army, In modern times, Marines and Army will both be the main force. As of 2024, the Army boasts about 500,000 active-duty soldiers, while the Marine Corps has around 180,000 active Marines. The grand alliance that luffy will command will consist of his entire Strawhats fleet, All Yonko crews, Minks, Samurai, Grand fleet, The Marines (including sakazuki) and the revolutionary army Vs Imu, the World Government, Cipher Pol, Blackbeard Pirates. Double that vs guys on horses with bows. If you want to go Marines go Marines. The 26th ID was a National Guard division Oh boy. I assume you mean Marine Raiders vs Recon. I really liked what he had to say and frankly the Marines have always had the reputation of being the most challenging. You’ll be a janitor regardless. xkeyrt twpxq tfrumsuj jco fzv rgeu hokoc uyir njn zejyql biwadmc tsfcgh nlmcfsa zdlxry cjoemrr